Thank you, Kathy! It is hard for me to keep track now that I have 2 dogs on the treat side of feeding. Chuck can have more than Teddy, but Teddy's always right there and wanting one too, so I feel bad for him. Measuring out the food and using it for treats is a good idea, so whatever they have left at dinner time is it. I love to treat the dogs, but that is how Chuck got up to 92 last winter. I gave him marrow bones and bully sticks plus other treats all the time. Now, I'm very strict about treats and he and Teddy both get just a few during the day. They get a bone maybe once a month now and try to get Teddy a smaller one than Chuck and not the marrow bones, but lamb bone or something without marrow in it. No more bully sticks either--Chuck can get through one of those in a minute, 2 at best. Teddy is so funny about his food--he always gets in front of Chuck, like me first, me first LOL, but he doesn't always get to be first, although Chuck could care less. I was told by one vet to give Chuck 900 cal/day and Teddy 400 cal/day. A nutritionist vet told me to give Chuck just 700 calories/day, but I didn't bring Teddy to her, so I can only imagine what she would say about his calories. So, I try to give Chuck between 700-800 and try to keep Teddy at 400. It's easy measuring the food out and keeping that in check, it's the treats for me that I have trouble with, so using their kibble is a great idea!